ARCTIC SEA ICE –The Mystery Of Drifting Salt–

Photo Credit for picture below: Matthias Wietz. From:  (Ice in this picture is only 1/16th of an inch thick)


The above picture of “ice flowers” has given me a lot of pleasure, as, first, it is beautiful, and second, it illustrates the complexity of sea-ice, which is beautiful in its own right, even if it can give our small minds a headache.

In the above picture a lead has opened close to shore, and the sea is exposed to bitterly cold air that is flash-freezing it. The very thin ice is actually wet on the top, because as salt-water freezes it exudes salt, which then melts the ice it is closest to, forming brine. This wetness eventually is pulled downwards by gravity, forming channels down through the ice and even “brinicles”, as seen in the cool clip below:

However when the salt is first exuded, before gravity can pull it down, it makes the surface of the ice wet with brine, and this brine evaporates, quickening the cooling of the surface, but also making the air just above the surface of the ice be super-saturated or super-cooled or whatever it is that makes ice-flowers form.

These ice-flowers turn out to be suburb wicks.  They defy gravity, by sucking the brine up, and not allowing it to sink down. In some cases I suppose the brine promptly melts the ice-flower, but in other cases the brine is pulled up into a region, sometimes only a distance as thick as a sheet of cardboard, which is so much colder that salt loses its ability to melt ice. And at that point, rather than melting the ice-flower, the brine freezes, and becomes part of the ice flower. This can continue until the ice-flower holds two or three times as much salt as sea-water.

Meanwhile very dry winds start to blow by, and then the H2O in the ice-flower starts to “sublimate”, which means it skips the liquid phase, and turns from solid directly into gas. The wind also can crumble these ice flowers, and they wind up as dust in the wind. As the water in the dust sublimates the dust increasingly becomes a fine powder of sea-salt, drifting across the surface of the ice.

Back in the late 1970’s I lived on the coast of Maine during some very cold winters, and actually  witnessed such dust blowing over the flash-frozen waters of the tidal Harraseeket River. The sea-ice was actually black ice and smooth enough to skate upon, which I think is rare for sea-ice, and I saw white dust blowing across the black ice, and making cracks in the ice stand out, because the white dust collected in those cracks. I dabbed a finger down and then tentatively licked it. It was salt, all right. I suppose I was being remotely scientific, but I just thought I was curious, and never thought my observation might mean something all these years later.

It may mean many things, and even contribute to the dreaded “Ozone Holes” at the poles, as I explained in this old post (towards the end):

However one thing I didn’t consider in that old post is what it means when you have drifting salt along with your drifting snow.

If you have ever lived in the north during very cold winters you know there are times salt works and there are times it does nothing, when you cast it on an icy driveway. Below a certain temperature salt has no effect on ice. Zip zero. Zilch. At the Pole this means the salt can blow around with the snow as just another white substance, up until temperatures reach a certain point.

The past winter saw many more leads form, due to the meridenal winds and the formation of more leads and pressure ridges than occur in calmer and more zonal flows. This created more salt to blow around with the snow, but it also may have created more temperature spikes, where the salt could start to melt the snow. Such spikes are due to Atlantic, (and less often Pacific), air being sucked north, and also are caused by the exposed water itself, which is far warmer than the air and warms the air until it is lidded by new ice. However these spikes are short-lived.

Because of this the snow starts to melt but then refreezes as the temperatures plunge and the salt stops having the ability to make snow sticky. The result is a starchy sort of snow called “(Insert word when I remember it)” that adventurers actually prefer to drifted powder, as it is easier to ski across.

What I have not seen discussed is the effect that the salt has around now, when temperatures rise to a point where the salt starts to melt the snow.

I can think of two differences right off the bat. First, the pools of melt-water would be more salty when they formed, and more able to melt downwards. Second, as everyone who has made ice-cream knows, adding salt to crushed ice drops the temperature.

In other words, heat was added to the air during the winter, as the salt was removed from the water, and as the water went through the phase changes from liquid to solid. Now those processes are reversed, and heat may be subtracted from the air.

So far there are only a couple slight dips slowing the rise of temperatures, which may or may not be indicative of the above-mentioned cooling occurring.

DMI3 0509B meanT_2016

I think it would be cool if the temperatures in the above graph dipped below the “green line”, because I could then suggest drifting salt contributed to the cooling. Sheer conjecture on my part, of course, but I always figure wondering is wonderful.

It would also be cool because, just as in some ways an El Nino is author-of-its-own-demise, creating a La Nina in the Pacific, it could be seen it was author-of-its-own-demise in the Arctic, by creating more drifting and blowing salt. (And this point might be driven home with especially keen poignancy if the cooling started in the Arctic before the Pacific changes could possibly get up to the Pole.)

(On the other hand, such cooling might be blamed on the “Quiet Sun”, rather than salt.)

In more mundane matters, the sea-ice extent continues to thrill Alarmists by being below-normal as it continues its yearly decline:

DMI3 0509B icecover_current_new (1)

The maps show the conditions remain quiet at the Pole, with the high pressure refusing to budge much.

Things are changing, though all looks quiet, and the clearest sign of the change is that the poor people of Iceland are finally getting a break from low pressure that seemed it would never leave, and now are getting some genuine high pressure.

However my hunch is that the real change will not become obvious until later, in late July. Then it will come as a shock.


In the meantime the only sign is the many pressure ridges on the horizons of all pictures we’ve seen from up there.

Obuoy 14 0509 webcam






13 thoughts on “ARCTIC SEA ICE –The Mystery Of Drifting Salt–

  1. Do you think we’ll see a record on the September minimum? Looks like the “recovery” in arctic sea ice has been completely erased.

      • The sea-ice extent will not be as low as it was when the Vikings farmed Greenland. And we will not die unless we head off and start farms in Greenland. After all, the backlash of a La Nina is waiting in the wings. I think this summer is the final hurrah for the Death Spiral crowd.

    • What do I think? Well, as a confessed layman and non-scientist, I have nothing to lose by venturing a guess. Nobody is going to fire me if I am wrong, for I don’t work funded by politicians or an university or Big Oil. This blog is the one place on Earth where I am king and boss and don’t need to take no guff from nobody, (with the not-so-small exception of my Creator.)

      No, I don’t think we will match 2012. The ice is thicker than satellites can sense, due to the many pressure ridges. The water is colder in Beaufort Sea due to the many exposures due to leads during the winter, and the water has been colder-than-normal south of Bering Strait, and even though the water there is now getting back to normal, the past has an influence when some of it has slid north under the ice. Even if we got a summer gale like 2012’s, I think the results would be different, and those gales are not a dime a dozen. If we get no gale the ice will be far more extensive on the Pacific side, I imagine.

      Many Alarmists list reasons to disagree with me, and think the ice is frail, and that the El Nino has stacked the deck in favor of melting. I think they will be as happy as cats in the cream until July, and then the extent graph will flatten.

      In the end, as always, we will see what we will see.

      • From their site:

        “11-May-16: Further NRT updates are suspended until the next winter season in September 2016. CryoSat is not able to measure sea ice thickness effectively during the Arctic summer due to melt ponds in the sea ice which interfere with the radar signal.”

        The close up views we have of the ice this year show more pressure ridges, which are difficult to include in the averages, as they are narrow compared to the wider areas generally flat ice. My assumption is that these winding lines of thicker ice will make the ice last longer. But we shall see.

  2. When I was much younger and the UK had traditional Weather Forecasts rather than the Climate Change ones we get now the forecast often referred to the Iceland Low. Which, as I recall, was a depression usually situated between Greenland and Iceland, and was blamed for the UK having a South Westerly prevailing wind.

    • Superb! (Nice music too!)

      The early shots show the pressure ridges I have been talking about. The lead that forms right across the airstrip late in the video forced a superhuman effort to create a new runway, and then to extend the far end of the new runway when the near end was warped by the shifting ice and wasn’t viable. The work the men do up there to create that “blue ice runway” is humongous, and this year must have taxed those fellows right to the limit. I’ll bet the pay is good, but they earn every penny.

      Thanks. I may post this video all by itself.

      • I am currently searching youTube. Man Oh Man, do I ever wish I understood Russian for this one: “Polar Target. Russian paratroopers in the Arctic”.

    • Thanks. I’ll check out the site when I have time.

      The ice did seem very fractured from visual satellite pictures, as the light returned this spring. Both old and new fractures, including some wide ones in Beaufort Sea. The thing I wonder about is where the ice piles up when the open water forms, and how much the sea is cooled as the open water freezes over.

      Beaufort Sea may have had more fractures in 2013. There were some huge leads that opened up in February that winter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s